Thomas Edison. Henry Ford. Du Ponts. Bushes. Rockefellers. The list of legendary figures who have escaped to The Beaches of Fort Myers & Sanibel is long and prominent. And no wonder. From the tarpon-teeming waters off Boca Grande to Captiva Island’s white-sand beaches to the rich subtropical ecosystem thrumming inside the J.N. “Ding” Darling National Wildlife Refuge on Sanibel Island, the area is a 1,200-square-mile coastal paradise that balances stunning terrain and outdoor adventure with historic preservation, cultural attractions, and an irresistible food and drink scene. Peak season runs from January through May, when blue skies and mild temperatures lure bird-watchers, beachcombers, and shell seekers, but there’s hardly a bad time to visit. Join G&G as we road-trip through this sunny stretch of shoreline with Design Darling lifestyle blogger Mackenzie Horan Beuttenmuller and her husband, Will.
Where to Stay
The Gasparilla Inn & Club
Since opening in 1913, the Gasparilla Inn & Club on Boca Grande has remained a pedigreed bastion of Old Florida charm. Awash in candy stripes, gingham, and floral, it is a feast for the eyes and other senses, and there is no shortage of activities on offer—from swimming, tennis, and tarpon fishing to golf on the seaside Pete Dye–designed course and, of course, plenty of good old-fashioned people-watching.
photo: Courtesy of Mackenzie Horan
Where to Eat & Drink
Not only does the the Gasparilla Inn & Club provide a respite from real life in the form of sport and wellness, it is also home to some of the area’s best dining. The Pink Elephant gets its name from the punchy umbrellas that adorn its deck, but it is the restaurant’s standout fresh catch—try the fish tacos—that makes the experience truly unforgettable. At cocktail hour, there’s no better sunset perch than the Gasparilla Inn Beach Club (house-made margarita in hand, of course). For early risers, the dining room serves decadent eye-openers such as lobster scrambled eggs, and the Inn Bakery, located a short walk away in the village of Boca Grande, specializes in breakfast and baked goods—plus a wide selection of caffeinated beverages—for those on the go. Back at the inn, BZ’s, a go-to stop on the main floor, stocks snacks and sundries.
photo: Courtesy of Mackenzie Horan
Another short walk from the Gasparilla Inn, the Loose Caboose—a Boca Grande staple—is housed in a former train depot. The restaurant is open for lunch and dinner, with a rotating selection of nightly specials, a midday menu heavy on no-frills seafood favorites, such as conch fritters and grouper fingers (caught locally, delivered daily, hand cut, and dished up with a side of house-made tartar sauce for dipping), and fresh ice cream made gelato-style with an unusually high percentage of heavy cream. Traveling with pets? No problem. The patio is Fido-friendly.
What to See & Do
Bailey-Matthews National Shell Museum
Conchology. Malacology. Shell identification and historical markers. If it relates to the area’s rich archaeological and natural wonders in shell form, it lives here. (The permanent collection also houses shells found around the world, as well as some of the largest shells on record.) Opened to the public in 1995, the Sanibel Island–based museum acts as a treasured national resource for scientists and shell enthusiasts alike.
Boca Grande Bike Path
This area began as a fishing village, so it’s no wonder that its bike paths traverse coastal beauty in a way that preserves both nature and a direct connection to the water. Take the six-mile paved Boca Grande Bike Path to explore the length of Gasparilla Island. Along the way, expect to spot iguanas, gopher tortoises, and plenty of sunbathers.
Jensen’s Marina Water Taxi
For an up-close view of Fort Myers and Sanibel’s transcendent, turquoise waters, schedule a boat ride through Jensen’s Twin Palm Resort & Marina. Not only is it an efficient way to travel from, say, Boca Grande to Captiva Island, but it’s also the most scenic route for everything from lighthouse-hopping to dolphin-watching. Rentals range from a twenty-four-foot pontoon to a sixteen-foot skiff; full tours and fishing guides are also available.
Sanibel Island Lighthouse
First lit in 1884, the Sanibel Island Lighthouse was one of the first lighthouses north of Key West, and it continues to beckon visitors today—not least because of the surrounding beach and pristine cypress-laden trails that beg to be explored.
To start planning your trip to The Beaches of Fort Myers & Sanibel, click here for more information.
John Brandon’s Florida Odyssey
A stranger-than-fiction road trip with the novelist and Sunshine State native John Brandon amid the swamps, springs, cemeteries, sinkholes, alligators, manatees, and real-life characters that inspired his epic Ivory Shoals
A Weekend in Bluffton, S.C.
Plan your escape to this enchanting Lowcountry enclave
High Hampton’s Intimate Allure
During the cooler months, the newly restored resort in Cashiers, North Carolina, transforms into the perfect couples’ getaway
Food & Drink
The Mad Scientist of Pawpaws
Largely the domain of foragers, the biggest edible fruit in the South has mostly been forgotten. A quietly obsessed Quaker from West Virginia has made it his life’s mission to change that
Food & Drink
How an Award-Winning Pastry Chef Doctors Up Boxed Cornbread
Even Kelly Fields whips up a box of Jiffy every once in a while. Here’s how she makes the store-bought stuff her own
Arts & Culture
The Top-of-2021 Reading List for Southerners
G&G contributors, editors, and Southern book lovers share new releases and old favorites to read right away this year—and a couple forthcoming releases already on preorder