Arts & Culture
11 of the South’s Best Rivalries (Besides Auburn-Georgia)
As Southern football teams compete for conference titles, tell us which other Southern rivals you’re pulling for
photo: Terry Manier
This year, the Deep South’s Oldest Rivalry is also its most recurrent. Auburn and Georgia, which met just three weeks ago, will square off again tomorrow in their 122nd matchup, this time for the SEC championship. Clemson and Miami will also meet on Saturday, in the ACC championship, and although not a long-time rivalry (they’ve met just 10 times), with teams this competitive, it probably won’t be long before one develops.
In the spirit of goodhearted competition, we’ve scouted some of the South’s other intense rivalries. Like the games this weekend, some are time-tested and others are up-and-coming. Where do your allegiances lie?
Little Debbie vs. MoonPie
Chattanooga, Tennessee, might as well be the snack cake capital of the world. In 1917, the MoonPie revolutionized the snack industry with its chocolate-coated-graham-cracker-and-marshmallow combination. Just down the road and a few years later, O.D. and Ruth McKee started selling what would become Little Debbie Oatmeal Creme Pies—and later, Swiss Rolls, Zebra Cakes, and Honey Buns.
Eastern vs. Western North Carolina Barbecue
Already divided between Blue Devil, Tar Heel, and Wolfpack fans, among others, barbecue is another thing that North Carolinians will never agree on. The dividing line separating Eastern and Western camps can be drawn—roughly—around Raleigh. To the East, chopped whole hog barbecue topped with a thin, vinegar-based pepper sauce holds sway. Western Carolina barbecue, also called Piedmont or Lexington-style, opts for pork shoulder, sliced or chopped, with a vinegar sauce reddened by tomato.
Coke vs. Pepsi
Coca-Cola and Pepsi have been competitors since their inceptions in the late nineteenth century. Pepsi is from New Bern, North Carolina, and Coke, of course, is from Atlanta. Although the colas have virtually identical ingredients, nobody thinks Coke and Pepsi taste the same. And everybody has strong feelings about their favorite.
Myrtle Beach vs. Pigeon Forge
When it comes to tourist destinations with a kick of kitsch, the South has plenty of options. Perhaps the most beloved—or most infamous—are Myrtle Beach, South Carolina, and Pigeon Forge, Tennessee. What’s better? A day at the beach followed by a round of putt-putt, a jaunt through Ripley’s Believe It Or Not!, and a concert at the House of Blues? Or a morning hike in the Great Smoky Mountains, an afternoon (and a funnel cake or two) at Dollywood, and dinner at the Dixie Stampede?
Georgia Brunswick Stew vs. Virginia Brunswick Stew
Everybody acknowledges that Brunswick stew is delicious, but people can’t quite come to an agreement on its origin. Brunswick County, Virginia, and Brunswick, Georgia, both claim to be the home of this hunt-camp staple. In Georgia, a large, rusty pot marks the spot where the first stew was made on July 2, 1898, but Virginia hosts a festival every year to celebrate the stew, born, it claims, during a hunting expedition in 1828.
Hatfields vs. McCoys
During the second half of the nineteenth century along the West Virginia-Kentucky border, the Hatfields, a wealthy timber clan, and the McCoys, a family of fewer means, became engaged in one of the biggest feuds in the country’s history. It began, some say, with a love affair between two of the children. Others claim it originated from a McCoy accusing a Hatfield of stealing his hog. Whatever the case, this rivalry planted itself in the American imagination and is built on a great Southern foundation: family honor, revenge, and pig theft.
ACC vs. SEC
Back in the day, these were largely one-sport leagues: The SEC dominated football, the ACC basketball. The playing fields—and courts—are more leveled now, but the question of sports supremacy remains.
Mardi Gras in Mobile vs. Mardi Gras in New Orleans
Although New Orleans’s parties and parades attract the most attention each year, Mobile, Alabama, is actually the birthplace of Mardi Gras—having started the tradition fifteen years before the Crescent City was even founded. Each city’s celebrations are unique: New Orleans’s Mardi Gras is more about the parades whereas Mobile places emphasis on its grand balls.
South Florida vs. Tampa Cuban Sandwiches
Chefs with a knack for Cuban sandwiches are serious about their craft. Each spring, a series of Florida festivals pits cubano makers against one another in preparation for the International Cuban Sandwich Festival held in Tampa each spring. The real crux of the competition, though: Whether Genoa salami belongs in the ham, Swiss, pickle, and mustard mix. That’s how they do it in and around Tampa. But in Miami and Key West, two more hubs of Cuban sandwich tradition, salami is heresy.
UGA vs. UNC
Okay, so they’re not really sports rivals—but the University of North Carolina and the University of Georgia do have a bone to pick with each other: Both claim to be the oldest public university in the country. And both, in their own ways, are correct. UGA was chartered first, in 1785. UNC didn’t receive its charter until 1789, but opened its doors in 1795—six years before UGA did.
A1A vs. Blue Ridge Parkway
From top to bottom, mountains to beaches, the South presents countless travel destinations and some very scenic ways to see them. The Blue Ridge Parkway in the fall is otherworldly, winding travelers through the autumn foliage between Tennessee’s Great Smoky Mountains and Shenandoah National Park in Virginia. At the region’s other pole lies State Road A1A, which runs through Florida along (and over) the Atlantic Ocean from Fernandina Beach to Key West, joining up with U.S. 1 at points to showcase more than 500 miles of beautiful Florida coastline.
Tell Us Your Great Southern Love Story
Have a classic photo of your grandparents’ wedding? A story of how your parents met? Share them here
Arts & Culture
Call for Nominations: Eagle Rare Life Award
Do you know someone leading a rare life? Nominate them for a $50,000 grand prize to be donated to charity
G&G’s Whole Hog Podcast
Listen to the brand new podcast from the editors and tastemakers of Garden & Gun
Food & Drink
The Mad Scientist of Pawpaws
Largely the domain of foragers, the biggest edible fruit in the South has mostly been forgotten. A quietly obsessed Quaker from West Virginia has made it his life’s mission to change that
Food & Drink
How an Award-Winning Pastry Chef Doctors Up Boxed Cornbread
Even Kelly Fields whips up a box of Jiffy every once in a while. Here’s how she makes the store-bought stuff her own
Arts & Culture
The Top-of-2021 Reading List for Southerners
G&G contributors, editors, and Southern book lovers share new releases and old favorites to read right away this year—and a couple forthcoming releases already on preorder