Food & Drink

Louisville’s Top Bourbon Bars

Where to find the best pours in Bourbon City

Photo: Courtesy of Neat

Neat Bourbon Bar and Bottle Shop.

Walking along Louisville’s Whiskey Row on a recent visit, I passed a jovial gentleman wearing a T-shirt that proclaimed: “I’m just here for the bourbon.” Something about his group and the late hour told me they probably weren’t picky about where their next drink came from, but they’d come to the right place. As enthusiasm for America’s native spirit continues to soar, Louisville has become the epicenter for bourbon tourism. And while there’s no lack of quality bars and restaurants in Bourbon City, several stand out for their distinctive atmosphere, comprehensive bottle collections, knowledgeable staff, and bourbon-focused service. Whether your whiskey knowledge runs deep or you’re embarking on your own journey of exploration, these ten spots set the standard when it comes to memorable pours.

Bourbons Bistro

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Bourbons Bistro (@bourbonsbistro)

Back when Bourbons Bistro opened in 2005—just as the modern bourbon boom was starting to take off—this cozy bar and restaurant in Louisville’s Clifton neighborhood steadily amassed national buzz for its whiskey collection (more than a hundred bottles!) and for offering exclusive single-barrel bourbons chosen by the bar’s owners and staff. While multi-page bottle lists and private-barrel programs have since become the norm, Bourbons Bistro is an early innovator that remains well worth a visit for its thoughtful selection of rare pours and barrel picks.

Doc’s Bourbon Room

Some bars go wide with a comprehensive collection of whiskeys, and some go deep by specializing in certain styles or offering various vintages of the same brand. Doc’s Bourbon Room, located downtown on Whiskey Row, accomplishes both. Any whiskey you’d like to try is likely on the encyclopedic bottle list, which claims to offer the largest selection in the state and numbers around 2,000. Suggested flights make it easy to explore themed pours, such as whiskeys finished in wine casks. Or try a vertical tasting: Want to sample every example of Angel’s Envy Cask Strength dating back to its original 2012 release of just 600 bottles? Doc’s has you covered.

Gertie’s Whiskey Bar

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Gertie’s Whiskey Bar (@gertieswhiskeybar)

Gertie’s Whiskey Bar originated in Nashville as an offshoot of the 404 Kitchen, helmed by chef and bourbon aficionado Matt Bolus. For Bolus, who was born in Louisville and visits Kentucky often for barrel picks, the city was the obvious choice to open a second location. The bar occupies a prime spot in the hip NuLu Marketplace, and the whiskey list leans toward Kentucky and Tennessee, with select offerings from top distilleries around the country and the globe, like a pour of the exemplary 12-year-old single-malt whiskey from Japan’s Yamazaki Distillery. In proximity of several restaurants, Gertie’s makes an ideal spot for pre- or post-dinner drinks. Try the perfectly balanced Split Decision, an amaro and whiskey cocktail, and choose between a Wild Turkey 101 bourbon or rye base to accentuate the drink’s subtle flavors.

Jockey Silks Bourbon Bar

View this post on Instagram

A post shared by Jockey Silks Bourbon Bar (@jockeysilksbourbonbar)

Jockey Silks has been a fixture of the Galt House Hotel—an iconic property on Louisville’s downtown riverfront this year celebrating its 75th anniversary—since opening in 1972. An original member of Louisville’s Urban Bourbon Trail, the bar and lounge ditched its darkly painted, old-school vibe in favor of sleek woods and upholstered leather during a 2019 renovation (part of a multiyear, $80 million update to the hotel). Settle into a high back lounge chair before heading out for the evening and peruse the hundred-plus Kentucky bourbons on the bottle list, which also notes each distillery’s proximity to the hotel.

Justins’ House of Bourbon

Equal parts tasting bar, bottle shop, and bourbon museum, Justins’ House of Bourbon—with locations in downtown Louisville and Lexington—lives up to its name with a deep selection, including many limited-edition bottles and vintage bourbons that are no longer in production, as well as numerous private-barrel picks. You can sample a pour at the well-stocked bar before investing in a bottle, or schedule a private tasting with one of the staff’s bourbon experts in the speakeasy hidden behind a bookcase crammed with rare whiskeys.

North of Bourbon

Bourbon Street meets Bourbon City at this recently opened neighborhood bar and restaurant. Chef Lawrence Weeks, who has Louisiana roots, riffs on Cajun and Creole classics for his lunch, dinner, and weekend brunch menus (start with a Frozen Kentucky Coffee and dig into a plate of grillades and grits). The food also pairs exceptionally well with a pour from the dozens of bourbon and ryes lining the back bar. Reserve one of the personal whiskey lockers and you can stash a few favorite bottles purchased from the bar so they’ll always be ready when you are.

photo: Courtesy of North of Bourbon
Inside North of Bourbon.

Neat Bourbon Bar and Bottle Shop

Though just opened earlier this year, Neat sports a lived-in, classic look with its red-leather bar stools, wood-paneled walls, pressed-tin ceiling, and whiskey ephemera decorating every nook. It’s an appropriate vibe considering the bar specializes in vintage bourbons. Located on a main strip in the Highlands neighborhood, this is the place to try a bourbon from your birth year (a pour from a bicentennial decanter of Old Grand-Dad in my case) or put together a flight of Very Olde Saint Nick from the ’90s. 

Proof on Main

photo: Courtesy of Proof
Proof’s bright gallery wall.

The flagship bar and restaurant in downtown Louisville’s original 21c Museum Hotel (look for the giant golden statue of David out front), Proof on Main immediately upped the city’s bourbon game when it debuted in 2006. It’s still a stylish, artfully eclectic destination for inventive cocktails like a Rhinestone Cowboy (rye, unaged apple brandy, dry curacao, pecan orgeat, concentrated lime, and bitters) and a bourbon list heavy on Kentucky distilleries, including numerous private-barrel selections.

Trouble Bar

You’re equally as likely to strike up a conversation with neighborhood regulars, industry insiders, and the bourbon curious during a visit to Trouble Bar. Best friends Kaitlyn Owens and Nicole Stipp, who also help plan customized bourbon excursions and classes, founded Trouble in 2019. There’s no kitchen (though you’re welcome to bring in takeout or order delivery), and the drinks menu is all about exploration and education. Try a themed flight, several of which are selected by bourbon luminaries, like “Bonded in Bourbon” by Samara B. Davis, the founder of Black Bourbon Society. A tasting guide further organizes the diverse whiskey list into lower-proof options, wheated bourbons, family-owned distilleries, and other helpful suggestions that make it almost a little too easy to while away several hours in the airy main bar.

Watch Hill Proper

photo: courtesy of watch hill proper
Inside Watch Hill Proper.

It’s worth venturing to the Norton Commons development, located about fifteen miles northeast of downtown Louisville, to visit Watch Hill Proper. Opened earlier this year, the clubby bar and restaurant recently loosened its “members-only” policy to welcome all into its inner sanctum, which features glass displays filled with vintage whiskeys, private whiskey lockers with brass nameplates emblazoned with some of the top names in the industry, and towering double-sided shelves stacked with bottles behind the main bar. The Whiskey Book (yes, book) lists more than 1,600 options, including bottles from nearly every state and more than 1,100 from Kentucky. Make your pick and sink into one of the cozy leather club chairs, or find a spot in the quiet library and peruse a selection of whiskey-themed tomes while you sip.