Food & Drink

Five Craveable, Chef-Approved Sandwich Spreads

Take your stacks to the next level with delicious, unexpected condiments

Jars of sandwich spreads

Photo: Johnny Autry


Up your home sandwich game with a handful of spreads from chefs across the South. You might be surprised by the perfect pairings: grilled peach chutney with melted grilled cheese, zippy artichoke chimichurri slathered on a po’boy, well-balanced banana ketchup aioli for breakfast egg sandwiches, no-fuss whipped feta suited for veggie wraps or BLTs, and crunchy harissa crisp to add subtle heat to a fried chicken sandwich. Get the recipes below.

biscuits
Stay in Touch with G&G
Get The Skillet, our weekly food and drink newsletter.

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Take your homemade spreads to the next level with buttery bacon fat brioche bread. Get the recipe here.

Find more in G&G’s Ultimate Guide to Southern Sandwiches here.


Jenny Everett is a contributing editor at Garden & Gun, and has been writing the What’s in Season column since 2009. She has also served as an editor at Women’s Health, espnW, and Popular Science, among other publications. She lives in Mount Pleasant, South Carolina, with her husband, David; children, Sam and Rosie; and a small petting zoo including a labrador retriever, two guinea pigs, a tortoise, and a fish.


Grilled Peach Chutney

Yield: 1½ cups

Ingredients

    • 1 lb. firm ripe peaches, halved and pits removed 

    • ½ small red bell pepper, stemmed, seeded, and quartered 

    • ½ small Vidalia onion, peeled and sliced in thick rings 

    • ½ cup light brown sugar 

    • ¼ cup rice wine vinegar 

    • 1½ tsp. minced fresh peeled ginger 

    • ½ vanilla bean, split (or substitute 1 tsp. vanilla paste) 

    • 1 tbsp. olive oil 

    • ¼ tsp. kosher salt 

    • ½ lemon, zest and juice 

    • ½ oz. good bourbon 

    • 1 tbsp. pickled mustard seeds (optional) 

    • ½ tbsp. chopped basil 

    • ½ tbsp. chopped mint


At Papi Queso, his grilled cheese–focused sandwich shop in Charlotte, owner and executive chef Brian Stockholm stuffs the gooey sammies with all sorts of things, from smoked brisket to spaghetti. For what might be the ultimate grown-up grilled cheese, he loves a combo of burrata, country ham, and this off-the-charts chutney that mixes flame-kissed peaches and Vidalia onion with vanilla, spices, and a touch of bourbon. “It is sweet and tangy with a hint of smokiness,” he says. “The recipe requires a little extra effort, but it’s worth it.”


Preparation

  1. In a large mixing bowl, combine peaches, bell pepper, onion, brown sugar, vinegar, ginger, vanilla bean, olive oil, salt, and lemon juice and zest. Toss everything together to dissolve the sugar. Cover with plastic wrap and marinate on the counter for 1 hour. In the meantime, preheat a grill to 350°F (preferably a charcoal or wood grill). Place peaches on the grill cut side down, along with the bell pepper and onion. Reserve the marinade. Grill until tender and slightly charred, turning to get all sides, about 6 to 8 minutes. Remove from grill and set aside until cool enough to handle.

  2. Combine reserved marinade and bourbon in a saucepan. Bring to a boil and let cook at a rolling boil for about 5 minutes, until liquid is reduced to a glaze-like consistency. Remove vanilla bean. Once the peaches have cooled, the skins should slip off. Dice peaches, peppers, and onions into ¼-inch to ½-inch chunks, depending on how chunky you want your chutney. Place into a mixing bowl and gently toss with the glaze, pickled mustard seeds (if using), and basil and mint. Taste for seasoning and adjust as necessary. Store in an airtight container in the refrigerator (best in the first 2 to 3 days, but you can store for up to a week).


Artichoke Chimichurri

Yield: 2 cups

Ingredients

    • 1 clove garlic, minced 

    • 1 shallot, minced 

    • 1 cup minced parsley, stems removed 

    • 1 cup minced oregano, stems removed 

    • ¼ cup minced tarragon, stems removed 

    • ¼ cup minced thyme, stems removed 

    • 1 (12 oz.) jar artichoke hearts, strained and minced

    • 2 tsp. red pepper flakes

    • Half an orange, zested 

    • 2 tbsp. red wine vinegar 

    • ¼ cup sherry vinegar 

    • ¾ cup sunflower oil 

    • 1 tsp. salt, plus more to taste


“I have many memories of eating butter-dipped artichokes on the back porch with my parents,” says Jason Sweeney, the executive chef of Asheville Proper in North Carolina. “It was always a special treat.” He combines that artichoke nostalgia with his favorite sauce, a bright chimichurri, in a condiment that lends the perfect finish to steak or seafood. “The flavor is very herbaceous, as all chimichurris should be, and the artichokes bring an extra nutty, earthy, slightly sweet flavor.”


Preparation

  1. In a large bowl, combine garlic, shallot, parsley, oregano, tarragon, thyme, artichoke hearts, red pepper flakes, and orange zest. Whisk in vinegars, then the oil, and finally the salt, adjusting to taste. Keep in a small jar in the fridge for up to 5 days (the vibrant green color of the herbs fades around the second day, but the flavor holds up).


Banana Ketchup Aioli

Yield: 1¾ cups

Ingredients

    • 1 (12 oz.) bottle Jufran banana sauce 

    • ½ cup mayo 

    • ¼ cup yellow mustard

    • 2 cloves garlic, minced or shaved on a Microplane 

    • 1 lime, zest and juice


A subtly tropical variation on the standard ’mater version, banana ketchup has been a staple in the Philippines since the 1940s. At Kultura in Charleston, South Carolina, chef Nikko Cagalanan’s spin on his homeland’s trademark condiment plays a key role in his scrambled egg and pork belly sandwich. “The aioli has the ideal flavor combination—sweet, salty, and acidic—to balance the fatty pork belly and complement the scrambled egg.”


Preparation

  1. Mix all ingredients together in a small bowl. Store in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to a week.


Whipped Feta

Yield: 2 cups

Ingredients

    • ½ lb. feta in brine (set aside ¼ cup of the brine) 

    • ½ lb. cream cheese, room temperature 

    • 2 tsp. minced garlic 

    • ¼ cup tightly packed basil leaves


“I think sometimes people are turned off by the idea of feta, but this spread winds up being so balanced,” says Bryan Lee Weaver, the executive chef at Butcher & Bee and Fancypants (due this summer) in Nashville. Since diners can’t get enough of Butcher & Bee’s whipped feta, he serves it as a dip and slathered on veggie and other sammies. For any leftovers? “The real secret is to break out a bag of Cool Ranch Doritos and finish it off.”

Preparation

  1. Break up feta into small pieces and place in the bowl of a food processor, along with cream cheese and garlic. Add ¼ cup of the brine from the feta and pulse a few times until everything is evenly incorporated. Add basil and pulse a few more times to incorporate into the mixture. There should be small flecks of basil throughout (be careful not to overmix or the feta will get a green tint). Transfer to the bowl of a stand mixer fitted with the whisk attachment. Whip on medium-high for 1 to 2 minutes until the mixture is fluffy, stopping to scrape down the sides as needed. Store in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to a week (basil may oxidize and turn brown after 4 or 5 days).


Harissa Crisp

Yield: about ½ cup

Ingredients

    • ½ cup extra-virgin olive oil 

    • 3 tbsp. white sesame seeds 

    • ½ tsp. coriander seeds, coarse ground 

    • ¼ tsp. cumin seeds, coarse ground 

    • 4 cloves garlic, minced 

    • 2 shallots, sliced thin 

    • ½ tsp. smoked paprika 

    • ½ tsp. cayenne pepper 

    • 1 tsp. salt


Beloved not only for its spice but also its texture, chile crisp is the buzzy Chinese condiment that’s become a pantry darling stateside for spooning onto eggs, pizza, sandwiches, and more. Chef Joe Schafer, vice president of culinary operations at Electric Hospitality Co. in Atlanta, created this version with a North African twist. “It’s oily and crunchy, but it has a different flavor profile with ingredients like cumin and coriander,” he says. “It’s less about the heat and more about the umami that makes you crave it.”

Preparation

  1. Heat a small saucepan over medium heat. Add olive oil along with sesame seeds, coriander, cumin, garlic, and shallots. Cook, stirring often, until the shallots are golden brown, about 6 minutes. Stir in remaining ingredients, remove from heat, and let cool to room temperature. Store in a well-sealed container at room temperature for up to 30 days.


tags: